Home / 2023 Congress / Abstracts

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

myRating

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

Moin Khan, MD, MSc, FRCSC, CANADA Saad Masud, BSc, UNITED STATES David Momtaz, MPH, UNITED STATES Marcel Betsch , MD, GERMANY Filippo Migliorini, MD, MBA, PhD, GERMANY Abdullah Ghali, MD, UNITED STATES Kyle Gouveia, MD, CANADA Timothy Leroux, MD, MEd, FRCSC, CANADA Ryan M. Degen, MD, FRCSC, CANADA

McMaster University , Hamilton, ON, CANADA

2023 Congress ePoster Presentation 2023 Congress Not yet rated

Anatomic Location

Shoulder

Diagnosis / Condition

Instability

Summary: There are many surgical procedures that can potentially be performed for anterior shoulder instability, but there is, limited head-to-head, high-quality data comparing these procedures. The aim of this systematic review and network meta-analysis is to provide a comprehensive overview, analysis and comparison of multiple surgical techniques that are used to manage anterior shoulder instability.

Background

Anterior shoulder instability is a common clinical problem; however, conflicting evidence exists regarding optimal treatment algorithms.

Purpose

To perform a comprehensive assessment and comparative analysis of stabilization techniques used to manage recurrent anterior shoulder instability.

Methods

Study design is a Bayesian network meta-analysis.PubMed, MEDLINE, Embase, and Cochrane databases were searched for clinical studies comparing surgical techniques for anterior shoulder instability. Two team members independently assessed all potential studies for eligibility and extracted data. Each included study underwent a risk of bias assessment using the Cochrane risk of bias summary tool. The primary outcome of interest was the rate of recurrent instability which underwent a Bayesian network meta-analysis. Additional analyses were performed relating to the degree of glenoid bone loss and the presence of osseous lesions.

Results

Of 2699 studies screened, 52 studies with 4209 patients were included. Patients who underwent open Latarjet demonstrated the overall lowest rate of recurrent instability (LOR 1.93; 95% CI 1.37 to 2.48), while patients who underwent arthroscopic Bankart repair demonstrated the highest (LOR 2.87; 95% CI 2.40 to 3.34). In the setting of 10-20% glenoid bone loss, open Latarjet had significantly lower recurrent instability (P=0.0016) compared to arthroscopic Bankart repair. When glenoid bone loss increased from 0-10% to 10-20%, arthroscopic Bankart repair had a significantly increased rate of recurrence (P=0.021). In the presence of an engaging Hill-Sachs lesion, both open Latarjet (P=0.01) and arthroscopic Bankart with remplissage (P=0.029) had significantly reduced recurrence rates when compared to arthroscopic Bankart repair alone. Open Latarjet had a high complication rate of 6.66%, while arthroscopic Bankart was lower at 1.24%. Finally, regardless of procedure, the presence of a Hill-Sachs or bony Bankart lesion was associated with an increased risk of recurrent instability (r = 0.44; P = 0.0003 and r = 0.40; P = 0.006, respectively).

Conclusion

The open Latarjet technique was found to have the overall lowest rate of recurrent instability, and significantly lower when compared to arthroscopic Bankart repair in the setting of increasing glenoid bone loss. It is, however, associated with a higher complication rate, which needs to be weighed when considering the procedure.

Arthroscopic Inferior to Superior Capsular Shift Results in Superior Clinical Outcomes Compared to Arthroscopic Bankart Repair for the Treatment of Anterior Capsulolabral Tears After Shoulder Dislocation ePoster Presentation Jose Castillo de la Peña, MD, MEXICO Ivan Wong, MD, FRCSC, MACM, Dip. Sports Med, CANADA
Outcomes of SLAP Repair vs. Biceps Tenodesis of SLAP Lesions in Females: A Retrospective Review ePoster Presentation Adeeb Jacob Hanna, BS, UNITED STATES Matthew P Wallingford, BS, UNITED STATES Emma Johnson, BA, UNITED STATES John Hayden Sonnier, MS, UNITED STATES William Johns, MD, UNITED STATES Sommer Hammoud, MD, UNITED STATES Brandon Erickson, MD, UNITED STATES Steven B. Cohen, MD, UNITED STATES Michael G. Ciccotti, MD, UNITED STATES Meghan E. Bishop, MD, UNITED STATES
Utility of Talus Osteochondral Allograft Augmentation for Hill-Sachs Lesions: A Cadaveric Study ePoster Presentation Phob Ganokroj, MD, THAILAND Justin Hollenbeck, MS, UNITED STATES Alexander Garcia, BS, UNITED STATES Bradley Fossum, BA, UNITED STATES Annalise Peebles, BA , UNITED STATES Ryan J. Whalen, BS, UNITED STATES Matthew T. Provencher, MD, UNITED STATES
Biomechanical Evaluation of Fixation Strengths of the Screw and Button Constructs in the Latarjet Procedure: A Cadaveric PSI Guided Latarjet Study ePoster Presentation Ashish Gupta, MBBS, MSc, FRACS, FAORTHOA, AUSTRALIA Brandon Ziegenfuss, BSc(Hons) MPH, AUSTRALIA Marine Launay, MEng, AUSTRALIA Nicholas Green, MEng, BDes, AUSTRALIA Kathirazhagan Stalin, MS Orthopaedics, DNB, MRCS, FAOA, INDIA Deniz Erbulut, PhD, AUSTRALIA Sarah Whitehouse, PhD, AUSTRALIA Jashint Maharaj, MBBS, FRSPH, AUSTRALIA Praveen Vijaysegaran, FRACS, AUSTRALIA Kenneth Cutbush, MBBS, FRACS, FAOrthA, AUSTRALIA
Epidemiology of Shoulder Instability Procedures: An Analysis of Complications and Costs ePoster Presentation Amil Agarwal, BS, UNITED STATES Jacob D Mikula, MD, UNITED STATES Suresh K Nayar, MD, UNITED STATES Sribava Sharma, MS, UNITED STATES Matthew J Best, MD, UNITED STATES Edward G McFarland, MD, FAAOS, UNITED STATES Uma Srikumaran, MD, MBA, MPH, UNITED STATES
Comparison of Slap Repair and Biceps Tenodesis: A Trends and Outcome Analysis ePoster Presentation Tim Kreulen, MD, UNITED STATES Amil Agarwal, BS, UNITED STATES Jacob D Mikula, MD, UNITED STATES Suresh K Nayar, MD, UNITED STATES Andrew Miller, UNITED STATES Matthew J Best, MD, UNITED STATES Uma Srikumaran, MD, MBA, MPH, UNITED STATES
Poor Clinical Outcomes and High Rates Of Recurrent Instability After Treating Seizure-Related Shoulder Injuries ePoster Presentation Davide Cucchi, MD, GERMANY Robert Ossendorff, MD, GERMANY Sebastian G. Walter, MD, GERMANY Tobias Baumgartner, MD, GERMANY Alessandra Menon, MD, ITALY Rainer Surges, Prof., GERMANY Pietro S. Randelli, MD, Prof., ITALY Max Julian Friedrich, MD, GERMANY
Similar Results After Latarjet Procedure Between Primary Cases And Revision Cases After Prior Arthroscopic Bankart Procedure ePoster Presentation Efstathios Konstantinou, MD, MSc, UNITED STATES Theodoros Mylonas, MD, GREECE Alexandros Koskiniotis, MD, MSc, GREECE Nikolaos Stefanou, MD, GREECE Georgios Komnos, MD, PhD, GREECE Socratis Varitimidis, MD, PhD, GREECE Michael E. Hantes, MD, PhD, Prof., GREECE
Anterior Glenohumeral Capsular Ligament Reconstruction With Hamstring Autograft for Internal Impingement With Anterior Instability of the Shoulder In Overhead Athletes ePoster Presentation Tadanao Funakoshi, MD, PhD, JAPAN Kozo Furushima, MD, PhD, JAPAN Toru Takahashi, MD, JAPAN Azusa Miyamoto, PT, JAPAN Toshiki Murayama, PT, JAPAN
The Raj Kumar (RK) Test As A Pathognomonic Test For Superior Labrum Anterior Posterior (SLAP) Lesions And Shoulder Instability ePoster Presentation Rajkumar S. Amaravathi, MBBS, DNB, MNAMS, FRCS, INDIA Padmanaban Sekaran, MSc PT, INDIA Rinju Krishnan, MS,DNB,MNAMS , INDIA Rahul Shah, M.S. Ortho, D. Ortho, INDIA Anoop Pilar, MS, DNB, INDIA Hemanth Kumar Alladu, MS Orthopaedics, INDIA
Overhead Athletes Have Equivalent Clinical Features and Postoperative Outcomes Compared With Non-Overhead Athletes After First-Time Anterior Shoulder Instability Events ePoster Presentation Zachary J Herman, MD, UNITED STATES Ehab M Nazzal, MD, UNITED STATES Ian DeYoe Engler, MD, UNITED STATES Janina Kaarre, MD MSc, UNITED STATES Robert Tisherman, UNITED STATES Justin James Greiner, MD, UNITED STATES Nicholas P Drain, MD, UNITED STATES Ajinkya Rai, BS, UNITED STATES Noel Carlos, MS, UNITED STATES Lena Vodovotz, BS, UNITED STATES Confidence Njoku-Austin, BS, UNITED STATES Albert Lin, MD, UNITED STATES
Non-Rigid Fixation Results in Higher Failure Rates Compared to Screws Following Arthroscopic Glenoid Reconstruction ePoster Presentation Luke Heinrichs, MD, CANADA Ivan Wong, MD, FRCSC, MACM, Dip. Sports Med, CANADA
Arthroscopic Latarjet Procedure Using Fibertape Cerclage – Clinical Outcome With Return To Work And Sports ePoster Presentation Sujit Jos, MS(Ortho), MCh(Ortho), MRCS Ed. , INDIA
Low Revision Rate After Arthroscopic Management of Shoulder Instability in Collegiate American Football Players ePoster Presentation Camila Grandberg, MD, UNITED STATES Ian DeYoe Engler, MD, UNITED STATES Nicholas P Drain, MD, UNITED STATES Janina Kaarre, MD MSc, UNITED STATES Adam J. Popchak, DPT, PhD, UNITED STATES Brian M Godshaw, MD, UNITED STATES Jonathan D Hughes, MD, PhD, UNITED STATES Volker Musahl, MD, Prof., UNITED STATES
Beach Chair Versus Lateral Decubitus Positioning For Primary Arthroscopic Posterior Shoulder Stabilization ePoster Presentation Bobby Yow, MD, UNITED STATES Ashley Bee Anderson, MD, UNITED STATES Patrick K Mescher, MD, UNITED STATES David J Tennent, MD, UNITED STATES John-Paul Rue, MD, UNITED STATES Brett D. Owens, MD, UNITED STATES Michael A Donohue, MD, UNITED STATES Kenneth L. Cameron, PhD, MPH, ATC, UNITED STATES Jon F. Dickens, MD, UNITED STATES
Influence of Graft Positioning During the Latarjet Procedure on Shoulder Stability and Articular Contact Pressure: Computational Analysis of the Bone Block Effect ePoster Presentation Rita Martins, MEng, PORTUGAL Carlos Quental, PhD, Prof., PORTUGAL João Folgado, PhD, Prof., PORTUGAL Ana Catarina Ângelo, MD, PORTUGAL Clara Azevedo, MD, PhD, PORTUGAL
Does the Use of a Single Anchor With Double Mattress Technique Suffice for Remplissage in Patients with Bankart and Hill Sach Lesions– An Analysis Of Clinical and Radiological Outcomes? ePoster Presentation Silvampatti Ramasamy Sundararajan, MS(Orth), INDIA Shivam Rajivkumar Shah, MBBS , MS (ORTHO), INDIA Ramakanth Rajagopalakrishnan, D.ortho, DNB(ortho).D.SICOT, INDIA Terence Dsouza, MS, DNB, FNB, INDIA S Rajasekaran, MS(Orth),DOrth,DNB,FRCS(Ed),FRCS(Lon),MCh(Liv),PhD, INDIA
The Influence Of Glenoidal Concavity On Shoulder Stability: A Comparison Between Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging ePoster Presentation Sebastian Oenning, MD, GERMANY Jens Wermers, MD, GERMANY Philipp Michel, MD, GERMANY Sebastian Oenning, MD, GERMANY Mats Jonas Wiethölter, MD, GERMANY Alina Köhler, MD, GERMANY Michael J. Raschke, MD, Prof., GERMANY J. Christoph Katthagen, MD, GERMANY
Arthroscopic PRP Injected at the Repair Site After Labrum Repair in Unstable Shoulders Give Improved Structural and Functional Outcomes: A Case Control Study ePoster Presentation Nitesh Gahlot, MBBS, MS Ortho, DNB Ortho, FACS, MNAMS, INDIA Sheikh Azharuddin, MS, INDIA Pawan Kumar Garg, MD, INDIA Saptarshi Mandal, MD, INDIA
The Biomechanical Efficacy of Tape Cerclage as an Augment or Standalone for Coracoclavicular Ligament Reconstruction ePoster Presentation Ian James Wellington, MD, UNITED STATES Benjamin C Hawthorne, BS, UNITED STATES Brian Ford, MD, UNITED STATES Caitlin G Dorsey, BS, UNITED STATES Kevin Quindlen, MS, UNITED STATES Bennett Propp, BS, UNITED STATES ELIFHO OBOPILWE, ME, BSc, UNITED STATES Paul J. Cagle, MD, UNITED STATES Augustus D. Mazzocca, MS, MD, UNITED STATES
Quality Assessment Of Youtube Content On Slap Tears ePoster Presentation Chelsea Matzko, BA, UNITED STATES Shreya M Saraf, MS, UNITED STATES Christopher Saker, BS, UNITED STATES Brendan O'Leary, BA, UNITED STATES Michaela A Stamm, MS, UNITED STATES Mary K. Mulcahey, MD, UNITED STATES
Open and Arthroscopic Posterior Bone Block Procedures with Iliac Crest Bone Graft for Posterior Shoulder Instability are Associated with High Complication Rates and Progression to Osteoarthritis - Systematic Review of Clinical and Radiological Outcomes ePoster Presentation Abu Zer Saeed, MBChB, BSc, MRCS, UNITED KINGDOM Nikhil Pandit, BMBS, BSc , UNITED KINGDOM Robert Jordan, MB BS, MSc, FRCS (Tr&Orth), UNITED KINGDOM Hubert J. Laprus, MD, PhD, POLAND Peter Alberto D'Alessandro, MBBS Hons. (UWA) FRACS FAOrthA, AUSTRALIA Ian K. Y. Lo, MD, FRCSC, CANADA Shahbaz S Malik, BSc, MB BCh, MSc (Orth Engin), LLM, FRCS (Tr&Orth), UNITED KINGDOM
Arthroscopic Coracoclavicular Stabilization with Augmentation of Acromioclavicular (AC) Ligament for Acute Severe AC Dislocation ePoster Presentation Daichi Morikawa, MD, PhD, JAPAN Hirohisa Uehara, MD, JAPAN Yoshiaki Itoigawa, MD, PhD, JAPAN Takayuki Kawasaki, JAPAN Yoshimasa Saigo, MD, JAPAN Muneaki Ishijima, MD, PhD, JAPAN
Assessing Bone Loss In The Unstable Shoulder: A Scoping Review ePoster Presentation Moin Khan, MD, MSc, FRCSC, CANADA Kyle Gouveia, MD, CANADA Fayyaz Rizvi, BSc, CANADA Danielle Dagher, BHSc, CANADA Timothy Leroux, MD, MEd, FRCSC, CANADA Asheesh Bedi, MD, UNITED STATES
Imaging Analysis of Arthroscopic Shoulder Stabilization: Comparison of Repair in the Beach Chair vs. the Lateral Decubitus Position ePoster Presentation Steven Jones, MD, UNITED STATES Alex Lencioni, MD, UNITED STATES Todd H. Baldini, MS, UNITED STATES Adam Seidl, MD, UNITED STATES Rachel M. Frank, MD, UNITED STATES

Menu

Search Filters

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

Background

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

More 2023 Congress Shoulder Instability ePosters

More 2023 ISAKOS Congress Content

Menu

Search Filters

Sign-in to ISAKOS

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

A Comprehensive Comparison and Evaluation of Surgical Techniques for Anterior Shoulder Instability: A Bayesian Network Meta-Analysis

Background

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

More 2023 ISAKOS Congress Content