Home / 2023 Congress / Abstracts

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Matthew J. Kraeutler, MD
UNITED STATES

myRating

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Jaydeep Dhillon, BS, UNITED STATES Matthew J. Kraeutler, MD, UNITED STATES Sydney M Fasulo, MD, UNITED STATES Mary K. Mulcahey, MD, UNITED STATES Anthony Scillia, UNITED STATES Patrick C. McCulloch, MD, UNITED STATES

Rocky Vista University College of Osteopathic Medicine, Parker, CO, UNITED STATES

2023 Congress ePoster Presentation 2023 Congress Not yet rated

Anatomic Location

Knee

Anatomic Structure

Cartilage

Treatment / Technique

Osteotomy Allograft

Cartilage

Cartilage Treatment Cartilage Injuries

Summary: Surgeons preparing for cartilage procedures of the knee joint should pay particular attention to preoperative malalignment of the lower extremity in order to optimize outcomes.

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to perform a systematic review to compare clinical outcomes of patients undergoing cartilage repair of the tibiofemoral joint with versus without concomitant osteotomy.

Methods

A systematic review was conducted according to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines by searching PubMed, the Cochrane Library, and Embase to identify comparative studies directly comparing outcomes between cartilage repair of the tibiofemoral joint alone versus cartilage repair with concomitant osteotomy (high tibial osteotomy [HTO] or distal femoral osteotomy [DFO]). Studies on cartilage repair of the patellofemoral joint were excluded. The search terms used were: osteotomy AND knee AND (“autologous chondrocyte” OR “osteochondral autograft” OR “osteochondral allograft” OR microfracture). Patients were evaluated based on reoperation rate, complication rate, procedure payments, and patient-reported outcomes (the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score [KOOS], the Visual Analog Scale [VAS] for pain, and satisfaction).

Results

Five studies (1 Level II, 2 Level III, 2 Level IV) met inclusion criteria, including a total of 1,747 patients undergoing cartilage repair alone (Group A) and 520 patients undergoing cartilage repair with concomitant osteotomy (Group B). Mean patient age was 34.7 and 37.5 years in Groups A and Group B, respectively, and the mean lesion size was 4.0 and 4.5 cm2 in Groups A and B, respectively. The mean follow-up time was 44.6 months. The most common lesion location was the medial femoral condyle (n=999). The two most common cartilage procedures were autologous chondrocyte implantation (n=883) and osteochondral allograft implantation (n=765). Preoperative alignment averaged 1.8 and 5.5 degrees of varus in Groups A and B, respectively. One study found significant differences in KOOS, VAS, and satisfaction favoring Group B. Groups A and B had an overall reoperation rate of 47.4% and 17.3%, respectively (p<0.0001). One study found no significant differences in complication rate and procedure payments between groups (p>0.05).

Conclusion

Patients undergoing cartilage repair of the tibiofemoral joint with concomitant osteotomy might be expected to experience greater improvement in clinical outcomes with a lower reoperation rate compared to cartilage repair alone. Surgeons preparing for cartilage procedures of the knee joint should pay particular attention to preoperative malalignment of the lower extremity in order to optimize outcomes.

Outcomes of Operative Fixation of Loose Trochlear Osteochondral Defects Compared Based On Skeletal Maturity ePoster Presentation Galo Bustamante, BS, UNITED STATES Amogh Iyer, BS, UNITED STATES Eric Milliron, BS, UNITED STATES Parker Cavendish, BS, UNITED STATES Spencer E. Talentino, MD, UNITED STATES James C. Kirven, BS, UNITED STATES Charles Qin, MD, UNITED STATES Ryan H. Barnes, MD, UNITED STATES Robert A. Duerr, MD, UNITED STATES Robert A Magnussen, MD, MPH, UNITED STATES Christopher C. Kaeding, MD, UNITED STATES David C. Flanigan, MD, UNITED STATES
Tissue Engineered Construct Showed Better Biomechanical Results for Articular Cartilage Restoration in a GMP Pre-Clinical Study ePoster Presentation Rafaella Rogatto De Faria, PhD, BRAZIL Joao Paulo Cortez Santanna, MD, MSc, BRAZIL Marina J. S. Maizato, PhD, BRAZIL Cyro Albuquerque, Prof., PhD, BRAZIL Daniela Franco Bueno, DDS, PhD, BRAZIL Arnaldo J. Hernandez, MD, PhD, BRAZIL Tiago Lazzaretti Fernandes, MD, PhD, MSc, Post-Doctorate, BRAZIL
A Novel Locking Plate System With Cannulated Screws For Medial Opening Wedge High Tibial Osteotomy: Clinical And Radiological Comparisons With A Conventional Locking Plate ePoster Presentation Eiji Kondo, MD, PhD, JAPAN Koji Yabuuchi, MD, JAPAN Koji Iwasaki, MD, PhD, JAPAN Masatake Matsuoka, PhD, JAPAN Tomohiro Onodera, MD, PhD, JAPAN Daisuke Momma, PhD, JAPAN Tomonori Yagi, MD, PhD, JAPAN Kazunori Yasuda, MD, PhD, Prof., JAPAN Norimasa Iwasaki, MD, PhD, JAPAN
Novel Solution Using Viable Cartilage Allograft For Focal Cartilage Defects ePoster Presentation Deryk G. Jones, MD, UNITED STATES Bhumit Desai, MD, UNITED STATES Graylin Jacobs, CRC, UNITED STATES Gerard Karl Williams Jr., MD, UNITED STATES Walter Stephen Choate, MD, UNITED STATES Scott C Montgomery, MD, UNITED STATES Brian M Godshaw, MD, UNITED STATES Misty Suri, MD, UNITED STATES
Surgical Management Of Osteochondritis Dissecans Of The Patellofemoral Joint ePoster Presentation Ryo Kanto, MD, JAPAN Tomoya Iseki, MD, PhD, JAPAN Hiroshi Nakayama, MD., Ph.D., JAPAN Shintaro Onishi, MD, PhD, JAPAN Yoshitaka Nakao, MD, JAPAN Shota Morimoto, MD, PhD, JAPAN Shinichi Yoshiya, MD, JAPAN Toshiya Tachibana, MD, PhD, JAPAN
Use of Fresh Frozen Osteochondral Allograft for the Treatment of Cartilage Defects of the Knee Functional Results And Failure Rate at a Mean Seven-Year Follow-Up ePoster Presentation Pablo Dardanelli, MD, ARGENTINA Nicolas Molho, MD, ARGENTINA Catalina Larrague, MD, ARGENTINA Juan Pablo Zicaro, MD, ARGENTINA Carlos H. Yacuzzi, MD, ARGENTINA Matias Costa-Paz, MD, PhD, ARGENTINA
MACI Case Series With Bone Involvement Requiring Autologous Bone Grafting ePoster Presentation Deryk G. Jones, MD, UNITED STATES Bhumit Desai, MD, UNITED STATES Jordan Nester, MD, UNITED STATES Graylin Jacobs, CRC, UNITED STATES Brian M Godshaw, MD, UNITED STATES
Reliability of Preoperative Planning Method That Considers Latent Medial Joint Laxity In Medial Open-Wedge Proximal Tibial Osteotomy ePoster Presentation Dong Jin Ryu, MD, PhD., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sung-Sahn Lee, MD., PhD., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Eui Yub Jung, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Joon Ho Wang, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Xenogeneic Cartilage Scaffold as a Promising Alternative for Full-Thickness Cartilage Defect Treatment: A Prospective Pilot Study on Clinical Outcome of Novel Bovine Cartilage Scaffold ePoster Presentation Dwikora Novembri Utomo, MD, PhD, INDONESIA Kukuh Dwiputra Hernugrahanto, MD, INDONESIA Lukas Widhiyanto, MD, PhD, INDONESIA Jifaldi Afrian Maharaja Dinda Sedar, MD, INDONESIA Dewi Masrifah Ayub, MD, INDONESIA Nicolaas C. Budhiparama, MD, PhD (LUMC, NL), PhD (UGM, ID), FICS, Prof., INDONESIA
A Prospective Observational Study Of Functional Outcome Of Leucocyte Poor Platelet Rich Plasma Therapy In Mild To Moderate Osteoarthritis Of Knee ePoster Presentation Umesha Chowdaiah, MBBS, D.Ortho, DNB (Ortho), INDIA
A Comparative Match-Pair Analysis Using Adipose-Derived Mesenchymal Stem Cells Plus Biplanar Tibial Open-Wedge Osteotomy In Treatment Of Varus Knee Osteoarthritis ePoster Presentation Matteo Baldassarri, MD, ITALY Diego Ghinelli, ITALY Alessandro Parma, MD, ITALY Sarino Ricciardello, MD, ITALY Luca Perazzo, MD, ITALY Roberto Buda, Prof., ITALY
Early Outcomes and Return to Work After Cartilage Repair in a Workers’ Compensation Population ePoster Presentation John G. Lane, MD, UNITED STATES Tyler Jordan Wipf, PA-C, UNITED STATES
Lateral Tibial Cartilage Slope and Meniscal Geometry in Patients With and Without ACL Injury ePoster Presentation Steffen Sauer, MD, DENMARK George Tsironis, MD, GERMANY
Maci Case Series in Patients With Multiple Osteochondral Defects ePoster Presentation Deryk G. Jones, MD, UNITED STATES Bhumit Desai, MD, UNITED STATES Jordan Nester, MD, UNITED STATES Graylin Jacobs, CRC, UNITED STATES Brian M Godshaw, MD, UNITED STATES
The Effects Of Running On The Development Of Knee Osteoarthritis: An Updated Systematic Review ePoster Presentation Jaydeep Dhillon, BS, UNITED STATES Matthew J. Kraeutler, MD, UNITED STATES John W. Belk, BA, UNITED STATES Anthony Scillia, UNITED STATES Eric C. McCarty, MD, UNITED STATES Jeremy K Ansah-Twum, BS, UNITED STATES Patrick C. McCulloch, MD, UNITED STATES
A Systematic Review of Randomised Controlled Trials Evaluating Injectable Orthobiologics for Knee Osteoarthritis: The Relationship Between Clinical Outcomes, Risk of Bias and Impact Factor Of Journal ePoster Presentation Patrick G Robinson, MBChB, MRCS, MS, MBA, UNITED KINGDOM Fares S. Haddad, MCh(Orth), BSc, FRCS(Orth), UNITED KINGDOM Robert F. LaPrade, MD, PhD, UNITED STATES Iain Robert Murray, MD, PhD, UNITED KINGDOM
Costal Chondrocyte-Derived Pellet-Type Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation vs. Microfracture for Repair of Articular Cartilage Defects ePoster Presentation Dae Keun Suh, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Kyoung Ho Yoon, MD, PhD, Prof., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Cheol Hee Park, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sang-Gyun Kim, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Jae-Young Park, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Yoon-Seok Kim, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Hee Sung Lee, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sung Hyun Hwang, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Bo Seung Bae, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Effect Of Patient History Factors On Meniscus Repair Outcomes ePoster Presentation Nathalie Sackey, BS, UNITED STATES Parker Cavendish, BS, UNITED STATES Eric Milliron, BS, UNITED STATES James C. Kirven, BS, UNITED STATES Spencer E. Talentino, MD, UNITED STATES Charles Qin, MD, UNITED STATES Ryan H. Barnes, MD, UNITED STATES Robert A Magnussen, MD, MPH, UNITED STATES Christopher C. Kaeding, MD, UNITED STATES David C. Flanigan, MD, UNITED STATES
Atelocollagen-associated Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation for the Repair of Large Cartilage Defects of The Knee: Results at Three to Seven Years ePoster Presentation Takuma Kaibara, MD, JAPAN Eiji Kondo, MD, PhD, JAPAN Masatake Matsuoka, PhD, JAPAN Koji Iwasaki, MD, PhD, JAPAN Tomohiro Onodera, MD, PhD, JAPAN Keita Sakamoto, MD, JAPAN Yoshitaka Oda, MD., PhD, JAPAN Zen-ichi Tanei, MD., PhD, JAPAN Daisuke Momma, PhD, JAPAN Shinya Tanaka, MD., PhD., Prof. , JAPAN Norimasa Iwasaki, MD, PhD, JAPAN
Tissue Engineering for Cartilage Repair: Pre-Clinical Trial Evaluation Methods ePoster Presentation Joao Paulo Cortez Santanna, MD, MSc, BRAZIL Tiago Lazzaretti Fernandes, MD, PhD, MSc, Post-Doctorate, BRAZIL Rafaella Rogatto De Faria, PhD, BRAZIL Vera Demarchi Aiello, MD, PhD, BRAZIL Carla Pinheiro, MSc, BRAZIL Daniela Franco Bueno, DDS, PhD, BRAZIL Arnaldo J. Hernandez, MD, PhD, BRAZIL
A Systematic Review Of Rehabilitation Protocols Following Matrix-Assisted Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation ePoster Presentation Jaydeep Dhillon, BS, UNITED STATES Sydney M Fasulo, MD, UNITED STATES Matthew J. Kraeutler, MD, UNITED STATES John W. Belk, BA, UNITED STATES Patrick C. McCulloch, MD, UNITED STATES Anthony Scillia, UNITED STATES
The Effect Of Injection of Secretome of Umbilical Cord Mesenchymal Stem Cells in Articular Cartilage Repair in Sheep Model ePoster Presentation Andri M. Lubis, Prof, MD, PhD, INDONESIA Andi Praja Wira Yudha Luthfi, MD, INDONESIA Jeanne Adiwinata Pawitan, Prof., INDONESIA Bambang Pontjo Priosoeryanto, Prof., INDONESIA Anissa Feby Canintika, MD, INDONESIA
Effectiveness Of Intra-Articular Injection Of Platelet-Derived Extracellular Vesicles For Treating Patients With Mild Or Moderate Knee Osteoarthritis ePoster Presentation Jonas Fernandez, MD, Ms Orth, MALAYSIA
Safety of Single Intra-Articular Local Anesthetic Infusion in Knee Arthroscopy: An In Vivo Histological Study on Rat Cartilage ePoster Presentation Antonios T. Kouzelis, MD, PhD, GREECE Ioannis N Vrachnis, MD, GREECE Dionysios Papachristou, Professor, GREECE Sophia Sourouni, MD,PHD, GREECE Andreas Panagopoulos, Associate Professor, GREECE Minos Tyllianakis, MD, PhD, GREECE Ioannis Gliatis, MD, PhD, Assistant Proffessor, GREECE
Medial Opening Wedge High Tibial Osteotomy Affects More than Just the Knee: A Study Looking at Changes in the Knee, Hip and Ankle Joints During Gait ePoster Presentation Sarah Bolton, MBBS, FRCS (Orth), AUSTRALIA David A. Parker, MBBS, BMedSc, FRACS, AUSTRALIA Myles R. J. Coolican, FRACS, AUSTRALIA Brett A. Fritsch, MBBS BSc(Med), FRACS, FAOrthA, AUSTRALIA Alexander S. Nicholls, MSc, FRACS, AUSTRALIA Yoong Lim, BEng, PhD, AUSTRALIA
Cellular Behavior In A Partial-Thickness Cartilage Defect Under Hydrostatic Pressure and/or Strain Mimicking Weight-Bearing and Joint-Loading ePoster Presentation Chilan Leite, MD, PhD, UNITED STATES Christian Lattermann, MD, UNITED STATES Shuichi Mizuno, Ph.D., UNITED STATES
Outcomes Following Gel-Based Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation for Articular Cartilage Defects of the Knee ePoster Presentation Dinshaw Pardiwala, MS(Orth), DNB(Orth), FCPS, INDIA Sachin Tapasvi, MBBS, MS, DNB, FRCS, INDIA Ashish Sudhakar Babhulkar, D(ortho),DNB(ortho),FRCS,MCH, INDIA David V. Rajan, MS(Orth), MNAMS(Orth), FRCS(G), INDIA Deepak Chaudhary, MD, INDIA Abhay Dattaram Narvekar, MS (Orth), INDIA Parag Sancheti, FRCS (Ed),MS(ORTH), DNB(ORTH), MCh(UK),Ph.D(UK), INDIA
Maci Case Series in Patients Aged 40 to 55 ePoster Presentation Deryk G. Jones, MD, UNITED STATES Bhumit Desai, MD, UNITED STATES Jordan Nester, MD, UNITED STATES Graylin Jacobs, CRC, UNITED STATES Brian M Godshaw, MD, UNITED STATES
Long-Term Clinical Outcomes of One-Stage Cartilage Repair in the Knee Using Hyaluronic Acid-Based Scaffold with Bone Marrow Aspirate Concentrate (Ha-BMAC): Thirteen Year Follow-Up ePoster Presentation Alberto Gobbi, MD, FRACS, ITALY Katarzyna Herman, MD, POLAND Dawid Szwedowski, MD, PhD, POLAND Anna Montagna, PhD, ITALY Leandra Bizocco, Dr., ITALY
RNA Sequencing Analysis of Neotissue Following Combined Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation with High tibial Osteotomy for Femoral Cartilage Injury with Varus Deformity ePoster Presentation Tomoya Iseki, MD, PhD, JAPAN Ryo Kanto, MD, JAPAN Shintaro Onishi, MD, PhD, JAPAN Yoshitaka Nakao, MD, JAPAN Nobuyoshi Suzuki, MD, JAPAN Takuya Iseki, MD, PhD, JAPAN Shota Morimoto, MD, PhD, JAPAN Hiroshi Nakayama, MD., Ph.D., JAPAN Toshiya Tachibana, MD, PhD, JAPAN
Imaging Evaluation of Physical Activity on Knee Articular Cartilage ePoster Presentation Marcus Vinicius Danieli, MD, PhD, BRAZIL João P.F. Guerreiro, MD, PhD, BRAZIL Felipe Santos LIma, MD, BRAZIL Luan Possani Rodrigues, MD, BRAZIL Jan Walter Stegmann Filho, MD, BRAZIL Arthur Gomes Rossitto, MD, BRAZIL Arnaldo Eder Kist, MD, BRAZIL João Luiz Francisconi, MD, BRAZIL Paulo Roberto Bignardi, PhD, BRAZIL
Preoperative Medial Tightness And Narrow Medial Joint Space Are Predictive Factors for Lower Extremity Alignment Change Toward Varus after Open Wedge High Tibial Osteotomy ePoster Presentation Sung-Sahn Lee, MD., PhD., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Young Keun Lee, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Dong Jin Ryu, MD, PhD., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Eui Yub Jung, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Joon Ho Wang, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Functional Midterm Outcome Of Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation With Spheroids Combined with Simultaneous Autologous Bone Grafting for Treating Osteochondral Defects of the Knee Joint ePoster Presentation Stephan Oehme, MD, GERMANY Sophie Krafzick, cand. med., GERMANY Tobias Winkler, Prof., MD, GERMANY Philipp Damm, Dr.-Ing., GERMANY Tobias M. Jung, MD, GERMANY
Effects of A Medial Opening-Wedge Distal Tibial Osteotomy Using Hemicallotasis (OWDTO-HCO) on Articular Cartilage of The Proximal Tibiofibular Joint ePoster Presentation Eiichi Nakamura, MD, PhD, JAPAN Hiroaki Nishioka, MD, PhD, JAPAN Nobukazu Okamoto, MD, PhD, JAPAN Tetsurou Masuda, MD, PhD, JAPAN Satoshi Hisanaga, MD, PhD, JAPAN Yasunari Oniki, MD, PhD, JAPAN
“Nuts In Jelly” Mosaicplasty for Medium to Large Chondral Defects of Knee – Functional Outcomes Up to 5 Years Follow Up ePoster Presentation Girinivasan Chellamuthu, MBBS, MS Ortho, FIOT, FASM, INDIA Santosh Sahanand Kulasekaran, MBBS,MS(ortho), INDIA David V. Rajan, MS(Orth), MNAMS(Orth), FRCS(G), INDIA
Particulated Costal Allocartilage with Microfracture vs. Microfracture Alone: A Multicenter, Prospective, Randomized, Participant- and Rater-Blinded Study ePoster Presentation Kwangho Chung, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Min Jung, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sanghoon Park, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Ki-Mo Jang, MD, PhD, Prof., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Chong-Hyuk Choi, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sung-Hwan Kim, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Costal Chondrocyte-Derived Pellet-Type Scaffold-Free Autologous Chondrocyte Implantation For Osteochondral Defects With Up To 10-Mm Depths ePoster Presentation Kyoung Ho Yoon, MD, PhD, Prof., KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Hee Sung Lee, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Cheol Hee Park, MD, PhD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF Sung Hyun Hwang, MD, KOREA, REPUBLIC OF
Return to Pivoting Sports after Cartilage Repair Surgery of the Knee: A Scoping Review ePoster Presentation Seikai Toyooka, MD, PhD, , JAPAN Gilbert Moatshe, MD, PhD, NORWAY Andreas Persson, MD, NORWAY Lars Engebretsen, MD, PhD, NORWAY

Menu

Search Filters

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

More 2023 Congress Knee Cartilage ePosters

More 2023 ISAKOS Congress Content

Menu

Search Filters

Sign-in to ISAKOS

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Cartilage Repair of the Tibiofemoral Joint with Versus Without Concomitant Osteotomy: A Systematic Review of Clinical Outcomes

Purpose

Methods

Results

Conclusion

More 2023 ISAKOS Congress Content